- After Hayden Panettiere as Ally goes missing, her small town erupts into a state of panic. Mr. Gibb, the awkward and unassuming teacher with a known infatuation with Ally, becomes the main suspect when it is discovered that he was the last person to see her before she vanished.
- Directed by:
- David Ostry
- Hayden Panettiere, Josh Hutchinson, Tim Daly, Sarah Steele, William Sadler